JB- Comparing the Canadian show and American show, CI was the first to allow instruments, is that right?
John- Correct.
JB- Now American Idol has added a fourth judge this season. What do you deduce from this?
John- I think they watch our show very carefully. I think there's a few things we do on our show that they could learn from. I think our show has more heart and soul. I think we're more, oddly enough in some respects, more proudly Canadian. Maybe because we need to be, because the jingoistic nature of America doesn't need that. I do, always have felt, that it's nation building. Port Hood is on the national stage. Toronto and Vancouver and Montreal are always on the national stage. These people come from these small towns and all of a sudden they put them on the national stage. I think that's an interesting aspect of our show. I think we introduce the idols to the Canadian public in a better way. Maybe not in a better way, but we DO introduce them to the Canadian public…
JB- In a real way.
John- Yes, in a real way. And not a bullshit way, not a horse shit way, not a fluffy way. We tell the real story: who they are. You know, I'm a painter. Earl runs a backhoe. I came from four generations of fishermen - and not to hide that but to celebrate it.
JB- It's not a pity party as we often see on the American show with the "feel sorry for me" kind of stories in the (video) pack.
John- Yeah, I'm a coalminer's daughter and something whereas we'd say, "Congratulations, you're a coalminer's daughter!" The pride is something that makes the towns feel good, makes the competitors feel good. It's interesting what happened this year. On the first top 10 show we went back and did hometown tours - we've never done that before in the top 10 show, we've always waited until the top 3 show - and we were staggered at that point, at the top 10 show, how many people showed up. It was like previous years once they made it to the top 3. The number of people that came out in the communities - you know, when Earl went home, I mean shit, I think there was 10,000 people or something.
JB- And some of these towns have probably never even had a TV camera there, let alone a whole crew.
John- It really is true. I think what Theo said in one of the packs [interview clips] tonight was when you're whole community comes together it's great when that happens.
JB- It's Canada.
John- It is Canada. It's reflected in our show and I'm proud of that. Why we wouldn't produce the show the same way as the Americans is because we're Canadians! So we produce it the Canadian way. They might do some things better than we do but we do it our way and I'm not going to copy them.
JB- But you represent the country the best that the country can be represented.
John- I feel we represent it honestly and also with a sense of humour.